Ramayana Faces Boycott Call Over Alleged Distortions

The Hindu Janajagruti Samiti has urged Hindus to skip Nitesh Tiwari's Ramayana, alleging that the film changes important incidents and character portrayals from the epic. The organisation has also demanded a special screening of Part 2 for religious leaders and Ramayana scholars before its release.

Ranbir Kapoor and Yash's much-discussed film Ramayana has landed in controversy after the Hindu Janajagruti Samiti (HJS) raised objections to its portrayal of characters and incidents from the Hindu epic. The organisation has appealed to Hindus not to watch the film, alleging that it distorts Maharshi Valmiki's Ramayana and presents certain characters in a manner that contradicts traditional accounts.

The controversy has also taken a new turn with the organisation demanding a special screening of the second part before Hindu religious leaders, saints and Ramayana scholars. It has warned of protests across the country if it finds similar alleged distortions in the upcoming instalment.

Why Has the Hindu Janajagruti Samiti Objected to Ramayana?

According to a report by The Times of India, HJS Goa coordinator Manoj Solanki said that several scenes in the film hurt Hindu religious sentiments. The organisation also held a press conference in Mumbai to explain its objections.

Its main concerns relate to the portrayal of Ravana, Lord Ram, Sita and Lakshman, along with the depiction of certain episodes from the epic.

The organisation has alleged that the filmmakers have introduced incidents and interpretations that are not present in Valmiki's Ramayana. It has also questioned the use of creative freedom when adapting a religious text that holds significance for millions of people.

However, these are the organisation's objections and interpretations. They do not establish that the film's creative choices are universally considered inaccurate.

HJS Objects to Ravana's Portrayal

One of the biggest objections raised by the organisation concerns Yash's portrayal of Ravana.

HJS has alleged that the film presents Ravana as a ruler who protects oppressed people and provides gold houses to the poor. According to the organisation, this depiction gives the demon king the image of a social reformer rather than the antagonist described in traditional accounts.

It has also questioned the film's portrayal of Ravana as someone who protects women's dignity, arguing that this conflicts with the traditional account of Sita's abduction.

The organisation believes these character choices change the audience's understanding of Ravana and his role in the epic.

Shurpanakha and Lakshman Episodes Also Face Criticism

The Shurpanakha episode is another major point of disagreement.

HJS has objected to the reported depiction of Shurpanakha approaching Lord Ram with a marriage proposal, followed by Lakshman cutting off her nose. It has particularly questioned a subsequent scene in which Sita reportedly reprimands Lakshman for disfiguring a woman.

The organisation has also objected to a scene in which Lord Ram reportedly apologises to the demons Khara and Dushana.

Lakshman's characterisation has attracted separate criticism. HJS claims that the film portrays him as arrogant, short-tempered and sarcastic towards Lord Ram and respected sages such as Vishwamitra and Agastya.

According to the organisation, Lakshman is traditionally remembered as a symbol of sacrifice, humility and devotion.

It has also questioned the film's depiction of Lakshman seeking knowledge of divine weapons from sages, arguing that the traditional Valmiki account describes Vishwamitra teaching the knowledge of Bala and Atibala to both Ram and Lakshman.

HJS Questions the Portrayal of Lord Ram and Sita

The organisation has also raised objections to certain battle sequences involving Lord Ram and Lakshman.

It alleges that the film shows the brothers retreating during battles against Khara, Dushana and their army, as well as Tataka. HJS believes these scenes do not match their traditional portrayal as courageous warriors.

Regarding Sita, the organisation has questioned a sequence in which she reportedly fights demons but does not resist when Ravana abducts her.

It has also raised an objection to Ravana's absence from Sita's swayamvar sequence, arguing that he was present in the traditional account but could not lift Lord Shiva's bow.

These objections form part of the organisation's broader argument that the film should remain closer to the traditional versions of the epic.

Special Screening of Ramayana Part 2 Demanded

HJS has asked the filmmakers to arrange a special screening of the second part before its theatrical release.

The proposed screening, according to the organisation, should include Hindu religious leaders, saints and scholars familiar with different versions of the Ramayana. It has also appealed to the government to take note of the concerns raised by religious organisations.

Manoj Solanki warned that if the second part contains similar alleged distortions, the organisation would take to the streets and oppose the film across the country.

The demand has added another dimension to the debate surrounding the upcoming sequel.

What Has the Ramayana Team Said About Different Versions of the Epic?

The debate also raises a broader question about adapting ancient texts for cinema.

According to a report by Cinema Express, producer Namit Malhotra has previously explained that the film draws from different celebrated retellings of the Ramayana, rather than relying exclusively on one version.

He reportedly pointed out that there are around 300 versions of the epic and that the filmmakers incorporated elements from different traditions while developing their cinematic narrative.

Directed by Nitesh Tiwari, Ramayana features Ranbir Kapoor as Lord Ram, Sai Pallavi as Sita, Yash as Ravana and Ravi Dubey as Lakshman.

With objections from HJS and a demand for a special screening of Part 2, the film's creative interpretation of the epic is now at the centre of a wider discussion about religious storytelling, cinema and artistic freedom.

Click here for the latest  news from Bollywood, Hollywood, South Film Industry, Bhojpuri and TV world… Click here to join the Facebook Page, Twitter Page, YouTube page, and Instagram of  Bollywood Mascot!

Share This Article
Gaurav Prabhakar
Gaurav Prabhakar

With over four years of experience in journalism and digital media, Gaurav Prabhakar is currently serving as the Editor-in-Chief at Bollywood Mascot. He is known for his expertise in news reporting, content writing, and editorial management, with a strong command over Hindi journalism and digital news publishing.

You Might Read: Ranveer Singh and Aditya Dhar May Reunite for 2028 Film

Leave a Comment